Creatine, past the hype
The most studied supplement on the shelf. What the research actually supports, the dose that matters, and the three worries people raise.
Creatine is the most studied supplement on the shelf and still the one people ask about most nervously. It has been in trials for more than thirty years. It is not new, it is not exotic, and it is not a steroid.
It is also not magic, and the way it gets talked about online has drifted a long way from what the research supports.
What it is
Creatine is a compound your body already makes, mostly in the liver, and that you also get from meat and fish. It sits in muscle and helps regenerate the energy your cells use for short, hard efforts.
Supplementing raises how much is stored. Vegetarians and people who eat little meat usually start lower and tend to notice more.
What it does
The consistent finding across the literature is modest improvement in performance in short, repeated, high-intensity efforts, and slightly better gains in strength and lean mass when it is combined with resistance training.
Note the second half of that sentence. Creatine works with training. On its own it does very little.
The size of the effect is real but small. It is not the difference between training and not training. It is a few percent on top of the work you were already doing.
There is a growing body of research on other effects, including cognitive performance under sleep deprivation and possible benefits in older adults maintaining muscle. That work is early. It is interesting rather than settled, and anyone telling you otherwise is ahead of the evidence.
The form and the dose
Creatine monohydrate. That is the form nearly every study used and it is the cheapest one on the shelf. The exotic versions cost more and have no good evidence of doing more.
Three to five grams a day is the standard dose. Loading phases, where people take twenty grams a day for a week, fill the stores faster. Skipping the loading phase gets you to the same place in three or four weeks. Neither is wrong.
Timing does not matter much. Consistency does.
The things people worry about
Kidneys. In healthy people, the research has not found harm at normal doses. If you have kidney disease, that is a conversation with your doctor rather than a question for the internet. Creatine also raises blood creatinine slightly, which can make a routine kidney test look worse than the kidney is. Worth mentioning before bloods, not worth panicking about.
Water weight. Yes, usually one to two kilograms in the first weeks, held inside the muscle rather than under the skin. It is not fat and it is not bloating in the way people mean.
Hair loss. This comes from one small study, in rugby players, measuring a hormone rather than hair. It has not been replicated. It is not nothing, and it is also not the settled fact it has become on social media.
Where it sits
Creatine is cheap, well studied and low risk for most healthy adults. It is also nowhere near the top of the list of things that will change how you feel.
Sleep is above it. Training consistently is above it. Eating enough protein is above it. Blood pressure is well above it. If those are not handled, creatine is a rounding error.
If they are handled, it is a reasonable, inexpensive addition.
One caution
This is general information, not a recommendation for you specifically. Supplements interact with medications and with conditions, and what is sensible for a healthy thirty five year old is not automatically sensible for everyone. If you take chronic medication, ask before you start anything.
Keep reading
The case for fixing sleep before anything else How the Novalife system works